Cases

Case Page: VA Chaplain Trubey – Freedom to Preach

In a major victory for religious liberty, the Secretary of Veterans Affairs has vindicated a chaplain who was wrongly punished for preaching a sermon on a chapter of the Bible his supervisor labeled “divisive”, reversed a Pennsylvania VA hospital’s effort to censor chaplains’ religious speech, and protected the rights of chaplains nationwide. Chaplain Russell “Rusty” Trubey, a respected…

Read More
River Front Apartments

Case Page: Pennsylvania Apartment Complex Discriminates Against Religious Tenants in the Name of Diversity and Inclusion.

Religious residents at an apartment complex in Pennsylvania for senior citizens and people with disabilities received an unwelcome surprise in their mailboxes in March of 2025. The apartment complex sent a letter to all its residents, explicitly banning them from having “Bible studies or meetings” in common areas. The rule also prohibited any religious materials, religious signs, or religious…

Read More
Mahmoud Rally

Case Page: Mahmoud v. Taylor

In Mahmoud v. Taylor, a group of parents from Montgomery County, Maryland, challenged a local Board of Education's policy. The policy mandated that elementary school students read books featuring LGBTQ+ themes without prior parental notification or the option to opt out. The parents, hailing from diverse religious backgrounds—including Islam, Catholicism, and Orthodox Christianity—argued that this…

Read More
Student doing homework

Case Page: Okhlahoma Statewide Charter School Board v. Drummond

Oklahoma Statewide Charter School Board v. Drummond is a critical case concerning educational freedom and religious liberty. At issue is whether Oklahoma can exclude religious schools from its charter school program solely because of their religious identity. St. Isidore of Seville Catholic Virtual School applied for and was approved as a charter school by the Oklahoma Statewide Charter School Board,…

Read More
Girls sports

Analysis: Pennsylvania Women’s Athletics & Sex-Distinct Sports Policies

April 2025 - Athletic teams have long been separated by male and female in order to foster safety, fairness, and athletic opportunities for women and girls. While sex distinctions were generally prohibited under Title IX, these reasonable sex-based distinctions were permitted, even required, in order to carry out Title IX’s purpose of creating educational and athletic opportunities on the basis of…

Read More
Male and female restroom

Analysis: Pennsylvania School Restroom & Locker Room Privacy

April 2025 - We show respect for the dignity of all people by providing separate space for males and females in instances where privacy between the two sexes is relevant, such as in restrooms, showers, locker rooms, and overnight accommodations like dorm rooms and hotel rooms on school trips. The distinctions between the two sexes is the reason our society has had separate locker rooms, showers, and…

Read More